Bookish Discussion

Books Vs. Movies: Which Version Should You Experience First? | Book Discussion

Hey Guys! I am Max and we will be composing the age-old debate on “Books Vs. Movies: Which Version Should You Experience First?” today. The introduction to book discussion topics is always the hardest for me to manufacture because I do not know how to dispense a puissant sentence after “Hey Guys” so, do not judge me so hard alright? I am attempting to make everything fall like a cascade of water – smooth and crystal-clear. 

Oh, and it’s currently raining outside, what a transcendent time to blog and read!

I had researched this topic on myriad websites and I will link the ones that gave me solid ideas on what I will be conversing on below to give them commendations for their crafts. Moreover, I will (maybe?) take quotes from the websites that I have mentioned and assert my own opinions on this topic as well. In addition, I will furnish you with statistics on the sides that people had placed their coins on. So, without further ado, let us get into today’s topic!


First of all, I would fancy conceiving a contrast between the time and length of a novel to the time and length of a movie. The time necessitated watching a film is normally more succinct than the time required to read and complete a full-length novel unless you are a remarkably agile reader. This happens due to the fact that a movie can only fit in so much important detail and discard the rest to fit a normal movie-length whereas a book can furnish the readers with character depth, developments, intricate details, sub-plots and a plethora of characters to encompass the readers with a more recondite desire to know the world and politics or the magic system in the novel work. However, movies are sometimes better than books because of certain repudiated information that nobody particularly enjoys and the metamorphosis of bad writing in the novel into something astounding in the film can be obfuscating to view but that is a sporadic sight as we are proffer with bad book to movie adaptations most of the time. For example, The Fifth Wave, Allegiant, Paper Towns & City Of Bones (2013) are not the most pleasant movies to watch but they are so much better to read about.

*The paragraph below is a little out of topic but it’s somehow related to the next, so don’t dismiss it!*

Secondly, I would like to announce that movies sometimes portray as a synergist for certain readers similar to me to accumulate novels that we have not hearkened or noticed before we watch the film adaptations of the novels. If the film adaptation is gallantly stunning to watch, it will give us an excuse to grab the novel(s) from the bookstore and start reading it/them or if the film adaptation is horrible, it will also coerce and motivate us to pick the novel up to perceive with our own eyes to judge whether or not the novel is as bad as the film which most of the time, is not. This paragraph, in turn, leads us to the next point.

Reading a full-length novel gives you a better insight into the intricately crafted plotlines than watching a film systematise the plot and the connections between the characters. Due to an overabundance of sub-plots, tension and drama in the characters’ lives, (provided that the author has given a detailed layout of their lives and carefully embedded their personalities and traits in the cleft of their skull) films are unable to render an effect the same as novels could. Therefore, films have to trim the edges and monopolise the critical points furnished from the novels to provide us with a coherent storyline instead of expediting a plethora of plotlines at the screen viewers and making an incongruous hodgepodge with plotlines. I think it’s more restorative to accommodate you with an example: The Harry Potter Movies made advancements towards certain topics that were sequentially left undiscussed in the movies but they were well explained in the novels. Thus, in order to watch the films, you must first read the novels to understand a wider scope of the world and its system.

Speaking of explanations, books make you think and visualise the settings in your head and the plot twists in them can be even more influential than the twists proffer to you in the movies. Unlike films, you have the freedom to decipher the author’s words in any way you want and it also capacitates your imagination to go beyond the wildest corners of your brain. The plot twists may be harder to decode in novels than in films due to a plethora of plotlines blemishing the truth. However, there may be exceptions. For example,  I thought the television series for Sharp Objects obscured the truth better than the novel ever did but I enjoyed both of them nonetheless. 

Lastly, you would exhume more dreamy words or capricious vocabularies from novels than you would in films. The reason behind this is because novels tend to explain and provide you with every little detail of an object or architecture that the protagonist lands his/her eyes on and that requires a lot of words to describe which will most of the time, lead to flowery language and gorgeous purple prose. In contrast, a film could not perform such an act as we are perceiving the surrounding of our protagonist in the film with our bare eyes while the film regurgitates information to its viewers – in other words, spoon-feeding the information to us. 

Well, in conclusion, both of them are for entertainment purposes (or educational purposes) and it is unmistakably up to you to select whichever material you want but I would highly recommend you to pick up the novel before you see the film to experience the vastness of the world, the flowery language, etc. that the author has to offer to you. 

I will now prescribe you with a few “book-to-film or TV series adaptations” that I personally enjoyed for you to chew on during the weekends:

  1. The Handmaid’s Tale (TV series)
  2. Big Little Lies (TV series)
  3. Call Me By Your Name (Movie)
  4. Before I Fall (Movie)
  5. Shadowhunters (TV series)
  6. YOU (TV series)
  7. The Fault In Our Stars (Movie)
  8. The Hunger Games Series (Franchise)

STATISTICS: I am not going to draw a graph because this is not a maths class so you are going to see a rough percentage here: Film – 11%; Books – 74%; Both – 15%. 

Websites that I gained several ideas from:

This is the end of my ‘Books Vs. Movies: Which Version Should You Experience First?’ bookish discussion article!  I hope you all enjoyed it and let me know what genre you tend to go for down in the comment box below! Follow me with your email/WordPress account to get notifications when I post a new article! Bye!

Bookish Discussion

Book Genres Tendency | Bookish Discussion

Hey Guys! It is Max here and I will be performing a self-evaluation on the book genres and their contents that I tend to gravitate towards today. I discern that this is not the usual content that I publish on my blog but I would like to manufacture a bridge between my old contents and my newer ones to allow you guys to perceive my transition process. Just for your information, this article will be placed under the category of bookish discussion. 

So, today we shall dwell on what genres I normally manoeuvre towards, study the pattern of its tracks and finally, how can I extricate myself from my comfort zone to read a diverse range of genres that I do not normally advance to. 

I hope this article will succour you to read other genres as much as it will assists me. Thus, without further ado, let us dive right into the discussion!


There was once a book genre named Dystopian which had embezzled the spotlight of multiple genres and advanced forward to a mesmerizing future until its throne was abdicated by other genres yet again. 

Yes, I am talking about the genre that produced a wondrous beauty like The Hunger Games. Yes, again, to the Maze Runner series and the Divergent series. 

To tell you the truth, I still read novels that exemplify the items in a classical Dystopia world such as corrupted government, compact and harsh lifestyles and deaths and my eyes often latch onto the books in a bookstore that meet those requirements. Guess what happens next? My hands are filled with those books while my legs are filing out of the store.

In all honesty, I figure that what makes a dystopian novel so popular is all convoluted with its addictive quality and its petrifying world. Sometimes, the plot of a dystopian novel can be absolutely balderdash in which you can take Divergent or rather- Allegiant as an example, however, with the help of those elements, it carries the readers through the unexpurgated novel without a sense of dismay and instead, a sense of ease in our hearts. Why?

It is because people enjoy reading about the characters’ pain and their journey to salvation. This may sound absolutely insane and I cannot speak for everyone but we need the action, the torturous pain in their expedition towards their goal and a good and not insta-love romance in these novels to make our heart fulfilled with joy and would instantly give a high rating to the novel.

I was once a die-hard dystopian fan and was not afraid to share my opinions about a dystopian novel among my friends even if our opinions differ. If you can postulate it right, I was that kind of fan that shunned other book genres and only read Dystopian until they had gotten tiresome.

Mind you, I still read Dystopian novels like I had said earlier but just not as much as I used to (just from time to time I will pick up a book from this specific genre to read). Dystopian novels had gotten such a bad reputation from others was merely because of the plot which was more or less the same, the characters which sometimes lacked personalities, the cliche plotline of this girl/boy who was meant to be the one to save this useless piece of shit society and finally, the uninspired romance which becomes tedious as more books in this genre get published.

That was when I realized I had to take a break from this genre and move on to the next. So, a tip:

#1: DO NOT wait until the last minute to convert yourself into another genre

It’s better to extricate yourself from one genre early if you notice that you are getting bored and tired of the same old boring plots which were brought about in books. If you remove yourself from one genre later than intended, you might not catch up with the other genres as there are so many books already released and it’s hard to catch up with the train-wagon. Honestly, only 35% of the people will survive that, others might just give up and jump back into their comfort zone- the dystopian genre. 

If you do not want to give up, read: for example, lite fantasy before pressing forward to the hardcore, everybody loves, high fantasy. High fantasy are for fans that have been moving about in that genre in a while so, in order to catch up, I advice you to read lite fantasy first to see if it is your cup of tea. Repeat the process with other genres too!


Moving on, we have the fantasy genre that has me captivated and obsessed until this contemporaneous time. Thanks to ‘I am Number Four’ By Pittacus Lore who introduced me to both Science Fiction and lite Fantasy, I was able to draw level with the incessant flow of Fantasy novels that were dominating the market. Additionally, I would also love to thank Laini Taylor’s prodigious series christened as Daughter Of Smoke And Bone. If it were not for that series, I would never have entered the High Fantasy zone. 

As for this genre, tip number one does not apply here because Fantasy has a broad range of sub-genres and elements. For example, a fantasy novel would sometimes include Urban Fantasy, Light Fantasy, Dark Fantasy, Science Fantasy, Historical Fantasy, etc. See? It does not always limit itself to a certain space and it allows readers to imagine the unimaginable and to view the inevitable. As for the elements factor, a fantasy genre be it a Light Fantasy or an Urban Fantasy or whatever has, again, a insurmountable amount of items to be filled into. For instance, a well-developed magic system, a plethora of settings, a diverse range of complex characters, a status of power, characters’ inner conflicts, greed, etc. All of these elements and sub-genres make a difference in each fantasy novels and that’s why Fantasy novels are entertaining and will never lack the quality of reading addiction unlike Dystopia.

However, traditional fantasy novels would sometimes become a chore to read as they often portray similar settings, conflicts and finally, offer one-dimensional characters. Not all Fantasy novels are like that but most of the popular ones are. For example, Beautiful Creatures by Kami Gracia and Margeret Stohl which I hated or The Kiss of Deception by Mary E. Pearson which I adored. These types of novels habitually engender a cleave between readers and I love the split as I could acknowledge other people thoughts on certain aspects and understand why they despised/loved a particular novel. As for that, I would like to give 2 tips to all readers:

#2: Do Not Be Afraid To Share Your Opinion

This tip may not coincide with the article that I am conversing on and may also be a little out of topic but I thought I had to stress on this because people of all ages have been afraid to share their opinions on a novel that they loved/despised due to the fact that they might receive ‘hate’ if one is to dispense their introspection into the world. I was once afraid of apportioning my reviews on books to the world because of the reason above but I pushed pass the thought and anxiety and bravely share it. Now, I feel so much confident to share my thoughts on a novel. Thus, I would like those of you who are afraid to not be petrified by those things. 

#3: Take a look at the synopsis of a Fantasy Novel before purchasing it

If you have been reading a tremendous piles of traditional Fantasy novels lately, you might be sick and tired of how cliche and similar everything is. Now, I would like you to read the synopsis of the Fantasy Novel first before reading/purchasing the novel as you could tell if the book’s content is similar to the ones you read earlier. Look for Fantasy Novels that you seldom see the contents of and read that instead of boring old cliche novels.

However, if you no longer have the interest in reading Fantasy novels, do not force yourself to fly through its text. You will not appreciate the content of it, so please move on to another genre until you feel like reading a fantasy novel again.


How does one fall into a genre? You might already be asking me that question as my previous tips did not necessarily provide any information regrading this topic so, I shall now furnish you with another one of my self-evaluation before I impart with a tip.

The Horror/thriller genre is tricky because the novels that are specifically dedicated to the genre might not live up to its expectation. For example, if a horror novel is not petrifying and lack the ambience of suspense and scariness, the horror novel did not manage to unnerve its readers and that could cause a rift between the author books and his/her readers by engendering the readers not to find interest in the author’s other works. The same goes to thriller novels.

I was not a huge fan of reading thriller novels before I read Night Film because there were many elements that I did not particularly enjoy. For instance, the lack of character development, the one-dimensional characters and the easy-to-guess plotlines and plot twists. However, after reading Night Film, I figure my knowledge on thriller novels was limited and thus, I began to read more and more novels from this genre.

As for horror, I have watched movies from this genre all my life and I adore the cinematography of them and with that in mind, I had decided to dedicate my time to read horror novels in book form and I am not going to lie, it was a colossal success. I read IT for the first time and was not disappointed with the horror genre and I am intransigent to read more books from this genre since I love it so so much.

Well, on with the tip:

#4: Read/listen to other people’s review

This is important because a person’s review would persuade you to try out the book which in turn, coax you to read books from the genre. I found ‘Night Film’ through Goodreads, Blog Reviews and Youtube by reading the reviews that were posted on that websites for the book and watching videos staunched to reviewing the novel and thus, allow me to view both the genre and the book in panoramic form. The same goes to ‘IT’. 

The genres are recommended by others through the books that they read and that was how I found my solace for each of them. You should try this method out too!


Finally, the Romance and Classic genre. The romance genre is novels for all seasons. Literally. I cherish the idea of picking up a romance novel whenever I am anchored by a reading slump, feel stressed out or I just want a novel that would cheer me up. Honestly, I figure that the romance genre is the most widespread because it can be in any books such as Fantasy novels with a hint of romance, thriller with romance, dystopian is always filled with romance and many more. It’s everywhere and it also has its own genre which is super popular.

What makes romance a good read? A cute couple finding love while disastrous events occur, a quickly paced romance novel, great characterization and HEA (Happily Ever After). Especially the last one.  

Classic novels, however, are hard to perceive the ones that you would adore. This, in my case, I would like to have other people who are more experienced in this genre than me to recommend me books that they think I would enjoy. People like school teachers, parents and reviewers. 

Just to name a few books that were recommended by teachers and reviewers: 1984, To Kill A Mockingbird, Animal Farm and The Handmaid’s tale.


By the way, the children genre is a joy to read. It is, again, for all seasons and ages!


There are genres that I did not mention such as Erotica and self-help books. Honestly, I do not think I will ever read Erotica because I do not enjoy reading about the mammoth piles of detailed sex scenes in books and I rather hate reading about them. Sorry if I have offended fans of this genre.

However, I have decided to start reading some self-help novels as I would like to improve myself as a human being and the ameliorate the good qualities and eliminate the amateurish qualities of my behaviour. Thus, I will be reading and reviewing some self-help books on my blog soon!

A tip:

#5: Set goals for yourself

Look for books from genres that you are desiring to read from on the internet and set goals for yourself to buy and intentionally finish reading the books from that particular genre. If you think the genre is quickly becoming one of your favorite, buy more novels from the genre and repeat the cycle of the tips that I have bestowed upon your shoulders.  

If it is not your cup of tea, move on to the next genre and repeat the cycle.

This is the end of my ‘Book Genres Tendency’ bookish discussion article!  I hope you all enjoyed it and let me know what genre you tend to go for down in the comment box below! Follow me with your email/WordPress account to get notifications when I post a new article! Bye!